|
I
have seen many paddlers in Greenland who appear to hold their
paddles with the blade more or less at a right angle to the
surface of the water. Maligiaq calls this a "beginner’s"
way of paddling. His grandfather taught him a stroke that he
had used as a seal catcher on Vester Eyland. This stroke is
done with the top edge of the paddle tipped forward about 40
degrees from vertical, according to Maligiaq. The angle is held
more or less throughout the stroke, including the return phase.
The drawing above illustrates how the paddler would see
the stroke if looking downward and to one side as he or she
paddles. The path followed by each blade for each stroke is
somewhat teardrop shaped, except that the working part of the
stroke appears to be more or less straight, as seen by the person
doing the paddling. During the return part of the stroke, the
blade moves forward as it is lifted out of the water, then it
curves downward again as it goes into the water.
Some
Americans who use Greenland-style paddles are skeptical of any
stroke that does not position the blade face at right angles
to the surface of the water. Most of my use of Greenland-style
paddles was in the ‘50s and ‘60s, and I don’t recall ever worrying
about it. It was simply a matter of paddling in whatever seemed
the most natural and comfortable way. However, when Greg Stamer,
an enthusiast of Greenland kayaking from Orlando, Florida, used
the "beginner’s" stroke while paddling alongside Maligiaq,
Maligiaq was using the stroke his grandfather taught him, Maligiaq
easily pulled ahead of Greg. Greg felt that he tired more quickly
than Maligiaq, even after making allowance for the fact that
Maligiaq was younger and had trained harder. That made a convert
out of Greg.
There
might be a theoretical advantage in using a narrow-bladed paddle
with the blades held tipped forward. A narrow-bladed paddle
tends to flutter more than a wide-bladed one, especially when
accelerating. This is because of vortex shedding, which is more
noticeable when one uses a narrow paddle. This phenomenon was
discussed in my article entitled "The Narrow Blade,"
(SK, Summer, ‘86).
When
a narrow paddle enters the water with the working faces at right
angles, the water tends to flow equally around each edge. It
makes a vortex that looks like a miniature tornado, along each
edge. The axis of each vortex is parallel to the edge.
However,
if the top edge of the paddle blade is tipped forward throughout
the stroke, the vortex will shed toward one edge all of the
time. It becomes predictable, instead of alternating, and the
paddler can compensate for and control it. This might be an
important factor in the effectiveness of this paddle stroke.
To
Greenlanders, the most important advantage of this stroke is
that it makes it easier for the working blade to slip out of
the water at the end of a stroke. The blade will climb out of
a wave while the paddler maintains his form and cadence. Several
other Greenlanders have confirmed the advantages of this paddle
stroke. All of them emphasized that they used this stroke to
help free the blade as it started forward on the return phase.
Maligiaq
used this stroke while racing against professional kayak racers
in Montreal "World Championship" races in 1999. Using
a Greenland paddle and a borrowed touring kayak with no rudder,
he competed against kayakers who used racing kayaks and wing
paddles. He made a respectable showing in the top ten, in spite
of having to paddle a lot on one side to compensate for side
winds.
Later,
in Miami, using a borrowed surf ski and a Greenland paddle,
he won first place in his category and second place overall,
beating several kayakers who used wing paddles.
|