Malone - Black Harbor
The Malone Black Harbor combines good looks, price and weight into an attractive compromise, especially if you prefer large blades. The shafts are basswood vertically laminated with dyed birch veneers; the blades are basswood edged with rock maple and tipped with polycarbonate. The clarity of the grain and its alignment looked very good. The paddle flexed considerably when pressed against a hard surface, but the flex was well distributed between the shaft and blade. The finish was excellent and virtually dust-free, with the gloss interrupted only by a couple of laminates with unusually porous grain. The fit of the ferrule was snug enough to be free of noticeable wobble, second only to the Mitchell paddle. The ferrule’s unusually large button was very easy to release.

The paddle seemed lighter than suggested by its actual weight. I was inclined to use a high-angle, aggressive stroke. Avoiding a noisy splash required a careful entry, which was rewarded with negligible ventilation of the blade. Although the blade seemed to plant strongly, my stroke felt slightly short, possibly due to some flexing of the shaft. A lower-angle stroke felt acceptable, although, on a few unusually careless entries, the blade tried to turn parallel to the surface. Gunwale clearance was good for such large blades on a short shaft. 
The smaller-than-average shaft and slick finish encouraged me to over-grip the shaft, tiring my hands. 
Slightly sanding the grip area would have allowed a more relaxed grip.

Sweep strokes felt quite effective, despite the short length, although I had to be careful to bury the blade fully. In sculling braces, the flow of water across the blade separated and made for a lot of splashing, but the support was good enough to keep the blade at the surface. Rolls felt effective, and the paddle was easy to maneuver underwater.

If Malone’s combination of a small-diameter shaft and large blades is appealing to you, the Black Harbor is a handsome paddle for the price.


Mitchell - Sea Blade