By John Heath
photos by Vernon Doucette
Several articles have appeared recently on the
subject of capsize rescue technique. My concern
is that the wet exit and reentry method has become
widely accepted in training programs as a first
option for rescues. It should be the last thing
to try, because it puts a capsize victim and others
at unnecessary risk. I recall having written decades
ago about the lessons that we might learn from
traditional kayakers who developed rescue methods
that have stood the test of time:
|
In
rescue, especially at sea or in lakes, the kayak
should never be abandoned and need not be if all
members of a group know Eskimo rescue methods.
Cold water quickly saps the strength of even expert
swimmers, and the time spent in practicing climbing
back in a kayak would be far better spent in Eskimo
rescue practice. ("The Kayak of the Eskimo," American
White Water, August 1961)
It is sad to realize that in the thirty-six
years since this article appeared, several kayakers
have been born, lived their entire lives and died after
making wet exits. They might still be alive if they
had known Eskimo rescue technique. My impression from
reading accident reports is that most capsize fatalities
occur after the victim makes a wet exit.
George Gronseth, who has authored many
of Sea Kayaker's accident reports, estimated that only
a very small percentage-say, one or two percent of
the victims in fatal capsize accidents-are found inside
their kayaks. The rest are found in the water, or missing.
Those found in their kayaks probably panicked or, in
at least one case, caught their footwear inside the
kayak.
Panic can result in a fatal accident, regardless
of whether one is in or out of a kayak. I believe the
most important obstacle to overcome in kayak training
is the fear of being upside-down underwater. The trauma
of a capsize begins with the shock of sudden immersion.
Then there is the discomfort caused by hanging head
down in the water. Water pressure on the nostrils is
hardly noticed when swimming underwater, but it can
be painful when upside-down. There is also the fear
of entrapment that makes us want to get out of the
kayak immediately, while we still have enough air to
reach the surface. If we can control the fear that
makes us want to bail out, we can find better ways
to survive than wet exits.
The subject of avoiding wet exits was addressed
in an article entitled "Please Remain Seated," Sea
Kayaker, summer 1990. It described various float and
snorkel arrangements that would permit a capsized kayaker
to remain in a kayak to roll up or part way up in order
to breathe and avoid panic until he or she could be
reached for an Eskimo rescue.
How paddlers adjust to underwater activity
is greatly influenced by the type of training they
receive. As an extreme example of the type of discipline
needed underwater, consider that required in military
special forces training. The August 1996 issue of Life
magazine contains photographs that should inspire all
sea kayakers to learn how to control fear underwater.
It shows U.S. Navy Seals training in a swimming pool.
To qualify as Seals, they must tread water for ten
minutes before retrieving their masks from the pool's
bottom with their teeth. But, they must do all of this
with their hands bound behind their back and their
feet tied together!
Fortunately, most of us do not have to
qualify as Navy Seals. There is a much easier way for
a kayaker to learn to control fear underwater. In 1985
and again in 1992, I attended kayak training classes
in Greenland. Before Greenlanders are taught to roll,
they put on their kayak jackets, which are fastened
around the cockpit, wrists and face. Then, without
a paddle, they lean forward with their faces near their
decks, wrapping their arms around the sides of their
kayaks so that their hands are on the bottoms. Keeping
the face near the deck makes the kayak easier to roll
and reduces water pressure on the nostrils.
The instructor, wearing boots or chest
waders, stands at the bow of the kayak, grasping it,
with one hand at the pointed bow and the other at the
forefoot, or forward end of the keelson, so he can
turn it over and right it again. When the student says
he or she is ready, the instructor turns the kayak
upside-down. After a few seconds, the student drums
his fingers on the bottom of the kayak and is immediately
righted by the instructor. The simple lesson here is
that the student, who is in complete control of how
long he or she wishes to remain under water, develops
confidence. The time that panic-control training buys
can be used to drum loudly against the bottom and sides
of the kayak while moving the hands vigorously to attract
attention. By dog paddling to the surface occasionally,
the victim can get a quick breath of air, then duck
under to conserve strength while holding both hands
up and waving them along the sides of the kayak.
If no help is nearby, the victim has a time-tested
Eskimo rescue method available, even though no paddle
is at hand. This is a roll that uses the buoyancy of
a float.
The Greenland hunting float, or avataq, is carried
on the afterdeck. One end of the harpoon line is
attached to the seal skin float, so that it can
be thrown overboard to act as a drogue for a harpooned
seal. In an emergency, it can be used for rolling
up if the paddle is lost. A fully inflated paddle
float can be carried on the afterdeck and used
as a substitute for the avataq.
To roll up on the right side, hold
one end of the float in the left hand beside the
right knee. Hold the other end of the float in
your right hand beside your right hip. Keep a lengthwise
tension between the hands as if expanding an accordion.
To initiate recovery, pull down toward the face
sharply with the left hand, leaning aft as the
float clears the front of your torso, then lean
forward as you become upright. At the finish, the
left hand will be beside the left hip, and the
right hand will be beside the left knee, in a mirror
image of the starting position. The hips and trailing
knee must rotate the kayak as you roll, and you
must coordinate the torso movement so as not to
lean forward too quickly. Extend the float outward
if more lift is needed for the recovery.
Try practicing this at home on the
floor until the movement becomes automatic. Holding
a pillow to simulate a float, pretend you are upside-down,
and move the pillow from your right side to your
left to learn the start and finish positions. Without
releasing your grip on the pillow, try a "roll" in
the opposite direction by reversing the hand movement.
Bow Rescue The simplest of assisted rescues is
for the capsize victim to grab the bow or stern
of a nearby kayak to pull himself or herself upright.
The reason for grabbing the end of the rescuer's
kayak instead of the middle is to avoid capsizing
the rescuer. It is preferable to use the bow so
that the victim is in full view of the rescuer.
If the victim paddles to the surface
for a breath and sees another kayak parallel to
his or hers, but out of reach, he can move toward
the rescuer's kayak by dog paddling to the side
while still inside the kayak. This might be the
quickest way to reach a nearby kayak if it is pointed
the wrong way to be easily maneuvered toward the
victim.
|
With the
victim still in his kayak, the rescuer can administer
CPR from a sitting position. |
 |
It's also better for
the rescuer's kayak to be parallel to that of the victim
to prevent a collision, and allow the rescuer to grasp
the bow or stern of the victim's kayak. By holding
the bow and bridging his or her paddle across both
kayaks, the rescuer's bow is automatically at or near
the victim's hand. Another advantage is that the rescuer
can keep the bow from swinging out of reach during
the rescue by moving the lower body.
This method was popular at Ammassalik,
East Greenland, in the early 1930s, when two Gino Watkins
expeditions were there. The book Northern Lights illustrates
this rescue. It is also shown in motion pictures made
during the Watkins expeditions. When used at roll practice,
the instructor can be in alignment for a parallel bow
rescue, yet well out of the way so that paddling alongside
can be done within seconds if a student signals for
help. When traveling in a group, an experienced kayaker
can follow behind and slightly to one side of a paddler
who is more likely to capsize. This same applies to
other rescues performed with the kayaks parallel to
each other. Being in the right formation, especially
when making wide crossings, can save much time in an
emergency.
The Paddle
The bow rescue requires that the victim is able
to grasp a bow and pull himself or herself up. A capsize
victim who is exhausted or unconscious can still be
rescued by one kayaker. If an unconscious victim and
rescuer are facing, it is even possible to reach underwater
and pull the victim's head up and across the foredeck
of the rescuing kayak. This position makes mouth-to-mouth
resuscitation possible without unsealing the spray
apron of either kayak.
The paddle bridge requires the kayaks
to be nearly parallel and just far enough apart
to rotate the victim up between the kayaks. The
rescuer makes sure that the paddle is firmly across
both kayaks with allowance for the victim's kayak
to roll under the paddle. The rescuer then uses
one hand to hold the paddle as a bridge across
both kayaks while keeping the other hand free to
assist the victim. An illustration and description
of the paddle bridge rescue appeared in Fridtjof
Nansen's book, Eskimo Life, published in 1891.
It and the other rescues described here probably
evolved over many centuries.
In
stormy seas, a paddle placed as a bridge across two
kayaks could slip out of position and cause the rescuer
to capsize, so it is more secure if the rescuer pulls
alongside so that the two kayaks touch. Then, extending
his or her paddle farther across both kayaks, the rescuer
reaches across the victim's kayak to grasp the far
gunwale. Once the kayaks are securely held together,
the rescuer can extend his or her paddle farther across
the victim's kayak to reach the opposite side.
Thus the paddle is across the foredeck of the rescuer's
kayak and cantilevered beyond the opposite side
of the victim's kayak. Then the victim can chin
up on the outboard side of the catamaran formed
by the two kayaks. As the victim rolls up, the
rescuer allows the victim's kayak to rotate under
the paddle bridge. |
 |
In
the storm rescue, the victim can help keep
the kayaks together in rough seas by chinning
up on the rescuer's extended paddle from the
outside. |
An advantage
of this rescue is that the victim helps keep the kayaks
together as he or she rolls up. A disadvantage is that
the kayaks bump together as the capsized one is righted,
which might cause hull damage to the kayaks or minor
injury to either kayaker. In an emergency, this risk
is insignificant, but care should be exercised in practice.
This rescue should only be used with strong
paddles, because there is greater bending load on the
cantilevered paddle than there is in a paddle bridge,
which supports the paddle at each end. In practicing
this maneuver, the rescuer should relax pressure on
the paddle at the first sign of excessive bending.
If the rescuer's
kayak is not in position for a parallel rescue, but the
victim's bow can be reached, the rescuer can pull the
bow of the victim's kayak across his or her foredeck,
and twist the capsized kayak so the victim can at least
get far enough upright to breathe and rest while
awaiting further help. It is important for the
victim to lean forward and wrap his arms around
the kayak to make it easier for the rescuer to
rotate it upright. |
| The Greenland "T" rescue
enables a capsize victim to breath and avoid panic
until further help can be given. |
 |
There
are also Eskimo rescues for extreme situations, where
a kayaker might get out of the kayak and have to be
carried piggyback on someone's afterdeck. This is extremely
dangerous in cold water. There was a poignant story
told by Dr. Alfred Bertelsen, a medical researcher
in Greenland around 1900. Three brothers were out hunting
in kayaks when one of them capsized. He exited his
kayak after failing to roll up. His brothers managed
to get him up between them, but he froze to death in
their arms.
These half dozen rescues will see a group
of kayakers through many emergency situations. It is
crucial to have practiced them as a team before an
emergency develops. Each person should take turns being
the rescuer and the victim. It is prudent to practice
these rescues under varying sea conditions. |
Advertising contact: paul@seakayakermag.com
|